Back to Blog

How to contest a will: grounds, deadlines, and costs

When I Die Files··9 min read
estate planningend-of-life planningfamily
How to contest a will: grounds, deadlines, and costs

The will was read on a Tuesday, and by Thursday Priya had stopped sleeping. Her father had promised her the house for twenty years. The will, signed eight months before he died and three months after his dementia diagnosis, left it to a neighbor who had started driving him to appointments that spring.

If something about a loved one's will feels wrong, you've probably wondered how to contest a will, and whether you even should. This guide covers who's allowed to challenge one, the legal grounds courts actually accept, the deadlines (which can be startlingly short), and what a contest costs in money and in family relationships. It isn't legal advice, and every state handles this a little differently, so treat it as a map for the conversation you'll have with a probate attorney.

Who can contest a will?

Only someone with legal standing can contest a will. In most states, that means an "interested person": a beneficiary named in the current will, a beneficiary named in an earlier version, or an heir who would inherit under state law if no valid will existed.

That last group matters more than people expect. If the will is thrown out entirely and there's no earlier one, the estate passes by intestacy, the default rules covered in our guide to what happens if you die without a will. So a child who was left out completely usually has standing, because they'd inherit under those rules. A close friend who was promised something verbally, with nothing in writing, usually doesn't.

Creditors sometimes have standing for narrow purposes, and in some states so do people named as executor in an earlier will. If you're not sure where you fall, a short consultation with a probate lawyer will usually answer it in the first ten minutes.

Grounds for contesting a will

Courts don't overturn wills because they seem unfair. The grounds for contesting a will are specific, and you need to prove at least one of them. Most cases rest on one of these:

  • Lack of testamentary capacity. The person didn't understand, at the moment of signing, what they owned, who their family was, and what the document did. A dementia diagnosis alone doesn't settle it. Cornell Law School's explanation of testamentary capacity notes the bar is fairly low, and people can have good days and bad days.
  • Undue influence. Someone in a position of trust pressured the person so heavily that the will reflects that person's wishes instead of the one who signed it. Red flags include a new beneficiary who isolated the person, helped arrange the will, or was present when it was signed. Cornell's overview of undue influence walks through how courts look at it.
  • Fraud or forgery, meaning the person was tricked about what they were signing, or the signature isn't theirs.
  • Improper execution. Every state has formal signing rules, usually involving two witnesses, and a will that skipped them may not hold up.
  • A later will or revocation. Sometimes the "contest" is really about producing a newer document, or showing the person deliberately destroyed the old one.

Undue influence and lack of capacity are the claims you hear about most, and they're also the hardest to prove. The burden is on you, the challenger. Courts start from the assumption that a signed, witnessed will reflects what the person wanted, and suspicion isn't evidence. Medical records from around the signing date, testimony from the drafting attorney or witnesses, emails, and a sudden break from a long pattern (say, five earlier wills that all split things equally) are what move a judge.

In Priya's case, the timing was suggestive. What actually mattered was her father's neurologist's notes from the week of the signing, and whether the neighbor had found the lawyer who drafted it.

How long do you have to contest a will?

Deadlines to contest a will are set by state law and are often short. Miss one and your claim is usually gone, no matter how strong it was.

A few examples show how much they vary:

StateTypical deadline
California120 days after the will is admitted to probate
Florida3 months after being served a notice of administration
Texas2 years after the will is admitted to probate
New YorkObjections are filed during the probate proceeding itself, often within weeks of receiving a citation

The clock usually starts with probate, not with the death. Once the executor files the will with the court and it's admitted, notices go out to heirs and beneficiaries, and that paperwork often starts your window. If you receive a probate notice and you have doubts about the will, don't set it aside to deal with after the holidays. The California Courts self-help center on probate is a good example of how states explain these notices, and your own state's court website will have something similar.

Exceptions exist for things like fraud discovered late, but you shouldn't count on one.

How to contest a will, step by step

The process looks roughly the same in most states, though the names of the filings change.

  1. Get a copy of the will. Once it's filed with the probate court, it's generally a public record, and you can request it from the court clerk.
  2. Talk to a probate litigation attorney early, ideally before the deadline is close. Bring the will, any earlier versions, the probate notice, and a timeline of the person's health and relationships in the year or two before signing.
  3. Gather evidence while it's still fresh. Medical records, care facility logs, texts, and the names of people who saw the person regularly all get harder to collect with time.
  4. File a formal objection or petition with the probate court that's handling the estate. Your attorney will handle the format and the grounds.
  5. Expect discovery. Both sides exchange documents and may take depositions from the drafting lawyer, witnesses, doctors, and family members.
  6. Mediate or go to trial. Many courts require mediation first, and most will contests settle before a judge ever decides them.

While the contest is pending, the executor usually can't distribute the contested assets. That's worth knowing if you're on the other side of this, too. Our guide to executor duties explains how a contest fits into the larger job of settling an estate, and what is probate covers the court process the contest happens inside of.

What it costs, and what it costs your family

Legal fees for a will contest vary enormously. One that settles after a few letters and a mediation might cost a few thousand dollars. One that goes through full discovery and trial can easily pass $50,000, and contests over large estates sometimes cost far more. Some attorneys work on contingency, taking a share of what you recover, which tells you something about how strong they think your case is.

Then there's the no-contest clause. Many wills say that anyone who challenges the will and loses forfeits whatever they were left. Most states enforce these clauses, but many make an exception if you had probable cause to bring the challenge. Florida won't enforce them at all. If you were left something modest and the clause is in there, your lawyer should walk you through exactly what you're risking.

The cost that's harder to put a number on is the family one. A will contest often means siblings giving depositions about each other, or a parent's medical decline being picked apart in a courtroom. I've heard more than one person say they won the case and lost their brother. That isn't a reason to stay quiet when something truly wrong happened. It is a reason to be honest with yourself about what you're hoping to get, whether that's the house itself or an explanation of why it went to someone else.

Sometimes a conversation does more than a court filing would. Before anyone files anything, it can help to ask the executor for the earlier wills, or ask the drafting attorney to explain the circumstances. Plenty of families find out the change had a reason nobody had heard yet.

If you want your own will to hold up

If you're reading this from the other side, wondering whether your own will could be challenged someday, a few habits make a contest much less likely and much harder to win.

Sign it properly, with the witnesses your state requires, and ask your attorney about a self-proving affidavit, which lets the court accept the will without tracking down witnesses later. Update it after major life changes so there isn't a stale version that conflicts with what you actually want. If you're leaving someone less than they might expect, or leaving something to a person outside the family, consider having the will drafted by a lawyer who meets with you alone and keeps notes. Our guide on how to write a will covers the basics.

And think about writing down your reasons. A short letter that says, in your own voice, why you left the house to the daughter who lived with you, or why you gave more to the son with three kids, doesn't carry legal weight the way the will does. It can still change how your family reads the will. People fight hardest when they feel erased or confused, and an explanation, even one they disagree with, gives them something else to hold onto.

When the will doesn't feel like them

There's a particular kind of grief in reading a will that doesn't sound like the person you knew. You're mourning them and also wondering whether the last thing they said to the family was really theirs. Both feelings can be true at once, and it's fine to take a few days with them before deciding what to do, as long as you keep an eye on the deadline.

Whatever you decide, the goal is the same as it would have been with them in the room: to make sure their actual wishes are the ones that count. Sometimes that means a court case. More often it means asking a few careful questions and learning something about the last years of their life that you didn't know.

If you're the one planning ahead, a letter can carry the reasoning your will can't. When I Die Files is a good place to write that letter now, explaining your choices to the people they affect, so they hear it from you rather than guessing in a lawyer's office.